City Tallies Cost of Blasting Issues at Wastewater Plant, Landfill

Monday, May 12 2014

It's been a year since Unalaska started uncovering big problems with a major construction project in town. Work is moving forward on the city’s new wastewater treatment plant. But as KUCB's Annie Ropeik reports, staff are still trying to put a price on the damage done.


[Sound of construction]

Workers at the wastewater treatment plant site are busy pouring concrete for the building's water tanks and foundations. City manager Chris Hladick says they’ll be able to start building the actual structure of the plant in the next month.

Hladick: "You know, they had planned on being further along than they are, but I don’t think it’s going to impact the total schedule."

The plant has to be online by the end of 2015, as mandated by a settlement with the Environmental Protection Agency.

Meanwhile, Hladick says they’re working on another issue -- one that was never supposed to be part of the project.

They’re trying to add up the cost of issues with blasting work done at the site last year.

Advanced Blasting was originally hired to carve out a hole for the wastewater treatment plant's foundations. But the city says they blasted too deep and too wide, and left behind explosive materials, including sticks of dynamite.

Advanced Blasting owner Julia Saunders has said the company won't comment on the allegations.

But contractors on the project say it's cost them at least $1.6 million -- and counting -- to deal with the blasting issues.

In some cases, the city’s agreed to pay what the companies are asking. They granted a $340,000 change order to Alaska Mechanical, the lead contractor, to fill in the over-blasted area.

But Northern Mechanical, the subcontractor at the plant, is asking for a lot more -- $1.3 million, to be exact. Hladick says the company did face a lot of extra work. They had to deal with the over-blasting and the abandoned explosives at the site.

Hladick: "It was completed last July and August, I believe, the work -- they’d find a blasting material and they’d stop work and deal with it, and there were a lot of starts and stops."

Northern Mechanical hasn’t been paid for that extra work yet, because the city wants more details on why it cost so much.

Hladick: "We’re saying, ‘Wow, that’s a lot of money. Okay, show us your back-up. Show us your timecards, show us how many trucks you used...' all that kind of stuff. And that’s well within our rights to do that."

Either way, it’s not just financial cost from blasting issues that’s adding up at the wastewater site. It’s costing time, too. Hladick says Alaska Mechanical wants to add extra days on the end of the contract to make up for delays.

He says that shouldn’t be a problem -- the city built a buffer into their construction schedule so they could meet the EPA’s deadline even if they ran into problems.

But all those problems have had a ripple effect, and it’s spread to another municipal project: the landfill expansion. Dynamite wrappers turned up in piles of rock there last month, bringing work to a halt.

The contaminated rock had come from the wastewater treatment plant, and Northern Alaska, the contractor that was supposed to use it to expand the landfill, needed to clean it up. Hladick says they asked for $2.3 million extra to do it.

Hladick: "That was just to go through 40,000 yards of rock, and they were going to go through it with a fine-tooth comb and make sure there wasn't anything in it. They had, like, $4,000 a day for a powderman to be on site, and they estimated 60 days to go through the pile."

The city thought the change order was too expensive, so they canceled the contract altogether. The project is set to go back out to bid this week. Whoever picks it up will also have to deal with the contaminated rocks.

That’ll all make up the final price of the blasting issues at the wastewater plant. Once the city approves the contractors' requests and tallies the total cost, Hladick says they'll bring it to Advanced Blasting and start looking at getting paid back.

Hladick: "Yeah, we're going to sit down with them and talk about it, that's for sure."

That conversation won’t involve lawyers -- at least not at first. But with projects worth more than $23 million total and several companies' reputations at stake, Hladick says it’s a definite possibility down the road.


Bright Side on Tuesday, May 20 2014:

WTH, how can it cost very much money to clean up after them last summer when no one actually shows up to work??? I walked by the hole last year and almost every time it was empty. Some equipment, but no men. When nobody works for 2 months, shouldn't cost that much for a few days of clean-up. And the "mess at the landfill" is laughable. We are talking about wrappers here, not a World War 1 minefield. But I agree with you on one thing. KUCB should get the real numbers and real story.

What the heck? on Monday, May 19 2014:

Bright Side. You should do a little more digging so you get the right numbers.... AB's original cost + cost of their change orders + cost to clean up their mess at WWTP site + cost to clean up their mess at the Landfill.... no way its less, give me a break. Complete nonsense. KUCB needs to give us the real numbers, real story.

Bright Side on Saturday, May 17 2014:

On the bright side, even with the explosives left on site, the total cost will still be less than Northern Mechanical's double for nothing bid on the original excavation contract. Now they want $2.3 million more to pick up some wrappers.

WTH? on Tuesday, May 13 2014:

Would like to see KUCB dig further into this...What would ATF/OSHA/MSHA say about explosives and wrappers left unreported at a job site? Exactly how much $ does Regan Engineering invoice the City for the "expertise and guidance" we receive from Tom Regan's firm?

Captains Bay Taxpayer on Tuesday, May 13 2014:

Talking about reputations!
First off our City Manager shouldn't have allowed this project get to this point.
And also Regan engineering was paid quite well to inspect and administer the Advanced Blasting mess! "The fox watching the Hen house."
Looks to me the repuatations on the line are our city mangers, Regan Engineering and Advanced Blastings.
Whose covering for who is the question the public deserves to know.

What the heck? on Tuesday, May 13 2014:

How much did the City already shell out to Advanced Blasting? Who the heck is in charge of these projects? Someone has to be responsible for all the money that is being handed out??? This is crazy that it even got to this point.

Just Saying on Tuesday, May 13 2014:

Way to go Hladick...keep costing the City more money...Great Job....:-(

Just Saying

Innocent bystander on Monday, May 12 2014:

Er-maybe the city should forget using the materials with the explosive debris and backfill instead with the stockpiled material contaminated with PCB's


News Community About Site by Joseph Redmon